“Openness of the Government” rating: from transparency to public
Language [#] en ua fr de ru es it Request a briefing NGO UCMC website Stream Press reviews Infographics About us About press center Contacts Regulations News Kyiv , March 06, 2017 “Openness of the Government” rating: from transparency to public dialogue дивитись українською watch in eng 1 / Kyiv, March 06, 2017. The issue of transparency of the government is important both for the media and the civil society. Experts of Better Regulation Delivery Office decided to make a research on how open institutions of the Ukrainian government are. Within a discussion on the results of the research they made suggestions about what should be changed in public communications to build confidence between the Government and the society. Among eighteen Ukrainian ministries, the most open is the Ministry of Infrastructure, which obtained 65 points of 70 in “Openness of the Government” rating, formed by Better Regulation Delivery Office. The next in the top-five are the Ministry of Education and Science (64 points), Ministry of Finance (59 points), Ministry of Regional Development and Construction (57 points) and the Ministry of Culture (53 points). At the bottom of the list are the Ministry of Foreign Affairs (24 points), Ministry of Information Policy (23 points) and Ministry on Temporarily Occupied Territories and Internally Displaced Persons (15 points). The results of the research were presented by Ihor Lavrynenko, analyst of Better Regulation Delivery Office, during a press-briefing at Ukraine Crisis Media Center. The rating is based on evaluation of compliance with 70 requirements on data openness which are compulsory for governmental institutions (one requirement equals one point). These requirements were united into 7 groups of criteria: compliance with the principle of information openness, providing open data, public plans of activity and reports, compliance with anti-corruption requirements and presence of public monitoring. The situation turned out to be rather positive with availability of open data and information openness, however, there are more problems with open access to plans and reports. “In total, the Ministries comply with nearly two thirds of legislative requirements on data openness,” summarized the expert. In Ukraine, public communications are usually politicized Openness of ministries’ websites which was analyzed within the research is just the minimum openness that is compulsory for governmental institutions, it should be a part of government openness in a broader sense. In Ukraine, there are deep problems in this field. “Frankly speaking, the majority of public communications in Ukraine are not state but obviously political communications, when political decisions are being “sold” to the general public, instead of being explained,” noted Yaryna Kliuchkovska, ВRDO expert. Absence of dialogue as an old tradition “There is an old tendency to legitimize decisions, instead of consulting different stakeholders and learning from the stakeholders. It’s not enough to keep people informed. It’s not really the issue of a website, or making more information available online, or having minister’s Facebook account, the issue is about having systematic attempts to consult people. Through this you will come to openness and credibility,” emphasized Jurgis Vilcinskas, head of Press & Information Section, Delegation of the European Commission to Ukraine. He noted that the European Commission always holds such consultations through various mechanisms. According to Yaryna Kliuchkovska, constructive dialogue will start as soon as both sides see opportunities it can bring. The state should change its attitude to public dialogue and perceive it not as a useless burden but an instrument which helps to take into account interests of the stakeholders and receive useful information and proposals for solutions from them. On the other hand, as soon as the stakeholders see that their voices are heard, they will come up with constructive proposals. According to Halyna Petrenko, deputy senior editor, editor of “Detector.Media”, communication between the government and the media improved over the past three years. However, several problems still remain, such as confusing structure of the websites, often vague or even run-around replies on official information requests. Recommendations to improve communication The ministries received general recommendations and special recommendation for each ministry based on the results of the research, which are expected to help them to fix problems. Ihor Lavrynenko noted that several problems were purely technical and now, one week since the recommendations were provided, several ministries have significantly improved their websites. Experts will also prepare recommendations with suggestions on how to improve legislation in this field, because a lot of the existing requirements are obsolete. Security of websites and protection of electronic means of communication are of primary importance. In addition, BRDO is preparing a new project to cooperate with the Ministry of Economic Development and the State Regulatory Service. They are going to create a “green book” with description of the most urgent problems of markets and then through public discussions with the stakeholders to draft a “white book” of solutions. Share Facebook Вконтакте Twitter Ukrainian crisis media center News Tags: BRDO відкриті дані відкритість уряду Мінінфраструктури публічні комунікації Subscribe to UCMC newsletter Subscribe SCHEDULE OF PRESS-BRIEFINGS IN UKRAINE CRISIS MEDIA CENTER FOR APRIL 13, 2017 10:15 Topic: "Anesthesia – everyone’s right: presentation of the information campaign #ZnimayRozheviOkuliary" Oleksandr Bratsiun, adviser to acting Minister of Healthcare of Ukraine on palliative care Andrii Rohanskyi, director of the NGO "Institute for Legal Research and Strategies" Kseniia Shapoval, program manager of the initiative "Public Health" of the International Foundation “Renaissance” Ukrainian house 2 Khreshchatyk Street 01001 KIEV UKRAINE 11:00 Topic: "Security in Kyiv during Eurovision-2017" Bohdan Lyzohub, Chief of Staff for security coordination during the preparation for and holding of Eurovision-2017 in Ukraine Yurii Nazarov, Director of the informational and communication technologies department of Kyiv City State Administration Ukrainian house 2 Khreshchatyk Street 01001 KIEV UKRAINE 12:30 Col. Oleksandr Motuzyanyk, Ministry of Defense of Ukraine spokesperson on ATO-related issues Ukrainian house 2 Khreshchatyk Street 01001 KIEV UKRAINE 13:00 Topic: "Open appeal of the Trade Union of National Museum of Ukrainian History to the Minister of Culture of Ukraine" Oleksandr Ishchuk, Ph.D., chairman of the grassroots trade union organization "New Time of the National Museum of Ukrainian History" Ivan Anhelin, deputy chairman of the grassroots trade union organization "New Time of the National Museum of Ukrainian History" Natalia Ivanchenko, Candidate of Philology, member of grassroots trade union organization "New Time of the National Museum of Ukrainian History" Ukrainian house 2 Khreshchatyk Street 01001 KIEV UKRAINE 13:30 Topic: "Presentation of the research by public organization ‘Employment Center of free people’” Maryna Lebid, head of the NGO ‘Employment Center of free people’ Ruslan Savchynskyi, sociologist of the research Yelyzaveta Kuzmenko, director of the research project Zhanna Lukianenko, representative of the Commissioner on the rights of internally displaced persons in the Secretariat of the Ukrainian Parliament Commissioner for Human Rights Fredric Larsson, Director of the Ukraine NGO Forum Ukrainian house 2 Khreshchatyk Street 01001 KIEV UKRAINE 14:00 Discussion: "Andriyivskyy Descent: goal - revitalization" Vitalii Biletskyi, representative of the NGO "Community Andriyivskyy Descent" Hanna Bondar, deputy director for planning and architecture of Kyiv City State Administration Serhiy Kazariants, member of the Union of Architects of Ukraine Tamara Mazur, Deputy Minister of Culture of Ukraine (TBC) Valentyn Mondryivskyi, head of Podolsk City District State Administration in Kyiv (TBC) Viacheslav Morskyi, member of the Union of Architects of Ukraine Bohdan Motuzenko, representative of NGO "Community Andriyivskyy Descent" Diana Popova, Director of the Department of Culture of the Kyiv City State Administration Iryna Prokopenko, General Director of the Kiev scientific and methodological center for the protection, restoration and use of historical, cultural and protected areas of Kyiv City State Administration Olha Rutkovska, representative of NGO "Community Andriyivskyy Descent" Moderator: Vladyslav Osmak, head of the Center of Urban Studies of the National University of "Kyiv-Mohyla Academy" Ukrainian house 2 Khreshchatyk Street 01001 KIEV UKRAINE Please support the Ukraine Crisis Media Center team in their daily efforts DONATE TO UCMC Latest news April 12, 2017 Ukrainian schoolgirl wins Mathematical Olympiad for the third time April 12, 2017 Meet some of the main people behind the Eurovision in Ukraine April 12, 2017 Fun Facts about Technical Production News on the topic April 07, 2017 Discussion: New legislation on passenger transport is progressive, but some aspects need broader discussion Ukrainian crisis media center News January 25, 2017 Lviv, Vinnytsia, Dnipro, Lutsk, Odesa, Kharkiv and Poltava city councils are leaders in publishing open data – research Ukrainian crisis media center News December 05, 2016 Procedure of the contest for the post of state secretary should be reviewed – officials, activists Ukrainian crisis media center News More news on the topic UCMC press center is a platform that allows civic activists, experts, politicians, authorities, diplomats and members of international community to conduct briefings regarding events and processes taking place in Ukraine. NGO Ukraine Crisis Media Center has no effect on media content produced during events at the UCMC press center, provides no guarantees and will not be liable for the content of information distributed by participants during the events held at the UCMC press center, including, but not limited to the participants distributing unreliable, untruthful, incomplete, inaccurate, invalid information during UCMC press center’s events or expressing their personal opinion. Furthermore, UCMC will not be liable for any damage resulting from such distribution or related to it or losses incurred by third parties. Ukrainian crisis media center 2014 - 2017 Powered by Plus One