KP Aids
Click on "BACK" to return to the News Full text Kyiv Post, April 26th, 2001 Opinion page 7 Chernobyl and HIV: preparing for the next 15 years Ukraine is on the verge of an AIDS epidemic that may be unparalleled in Europe. It is hard to forecast any epidemic let alone one that deals with sexual contact and intravenous drug use. Never-Owless, Ukraine has one of the fastest-growing rates of HIV prevalence in the world at this time. Ukraine, like many other countries, has been slow in responding. On the other hand, Ukraine has the advantage of being able to observe how other countries have grappled with the AIDS problem. At the same time, Ukraine is a fully literate country with a well-educated populace, where the understanding of an issue as complex as the HIV epidemic should be a foregone conclusion. A decisive and effective strategy may prove to be another matter. I witnessed and "took care of" my first case of AIDS in inner city Brooklyn, New York in 1978, three years before the disease was officially recognized. I not only foresaw the disaster that unfolded but decided to pursue a WK Kellogg Foundation Fellowship at Harvard from 1981 to 1983 to begin to understand how such an epidemic could and should occur in an advanced society like America. As Yogi Bem would put it, I went through deja vu all over again when the Soviet Union began to break up. I remember telling some of the hosts of the touring Virsky Baliet in Schenectady, New York, in 1997 that they should warn the dancers about the dangers of AIDS. An interview I gave for RFE/RL in 1993 or 1994 was heavily censored and bore no resemblance to what I had said. To see AIDS unfold in a second country one is involved in emotionally results in some introspection. So what words of wisdom can I give? None, I guess. Every country has to go down its own paath. An old man cannot teach a young kid to bicycle. Nevertheless, I will share several impressions. UKRAINE MUST IDENTIFY ITS OWN VULNERABILITIES The Human Immunodeficiency Virus finds its own ecological niche whether it is the United States, Australia, Zimbabwe or Ukraine. HIV is an opportunist that can only infect vulnerable populations. Without dirty syringes, blood transfusions, and sexual intercourse it cannot propagate. It is the product of human folly. As a medical student in Brooklyn from 1970 to 1974, I had two types of patients who became the seeds of the epidemic in the United States. Intra-venous drug users were acquiring ever more severe and resistant infections of every variety. They went through a revolving door of non-care that only aggravated this problem. More were also de-institutionalized psychotic men who thought nothing of having 40 anonymous sexual partners in a day, or 12,000 a year. It took years and some civil disobedience for New York State to permit needle exchange programs. Eventually the New York City Department of Health even closed nearly all the public toilets and public bath houses in New York City. In Ukraine, the two vulnerable populations would appear to be the women who will return home from white slavery both at home and abroad, and drug users. Like the psychotic men in America, women who work in the sex trade abroad entertain thousands of customers a year. As for the drug users, they mainly consist of the deeply cynical young men of industrial Ukraine, who use the Polish-invented poppy "kompof' and other forms of cheap, mixed and shared heroin. Neither of these two groups can be considered priorities of Ukrainian health officials. They cannot pay for their own care. But they have to be made partners in the fight against AIDS. There is no alternative. CORRUPTION KILLS A government that is at war with itself and is obsessed with its own dysfunctionality is not likely to recognize AIDS as a priority. Health care in Ukraine has been turned into a market oriented service for the newly affluent. If the Ukrainian government continues to fail to draw up a series of health priorities, Aids will run its full course. At the same time, one person's needle exchange program is another person's black-market product. Corruption within a needle-exchange program is likely to lead to even wider dissemination of HIV. The availability of retroviral products on the black market is likely to lead to HIV resistance. The same holds true for all the associated epidemics, such as tuberculosis, syphilis and gonorrhea. AIDS IS INTRINSICALLY CONTROVERSIAL If you are human, you cannot deal with AIDS and not offend someone. Only true Solomons and saints can tread the dangerous political paths of AIDS. One person's sex-education program is another person's anathema. One person's needle-exchange program is another person's permissiveness. One person's orphan is another person's ogre. In a society like Ukraine, where tolerance is a relatively new phenomenon, dealing with the complex, sociopolitical issues of AIDS will prove to be particularly troublesome. The emergence of frank discussion about sexual orientation and drug use in the West is a byproduct of the AIDS epidemic. It is time that it begins in Ukraine. EDUCATION SAVES LIVES There is no cure for AIDS. Ukraine can afford very few of the effective treatments. Universal education is the only effective measure at Ukraine's disposal. That education has to begin with the president's office and seep down. It has to start with the street urchins of Kyiv and seep up. All media and all parts of society have to cooperate. The current free-drug initiative in Africa will not save lives. Although I greatly appreciate and support the initiatives to make many anti-HIV medications available at generic prices in Africa and Brazil, I am skeptical that this effort will save lives. Medications have to be taken around the clock in complex doses with frequent instructions, adjustments and related care. Most drug addicts and other victims of AIDS are too strung out to cooperate without an equally expensive medical infrastructure. In the same vein, there will be no vaccine against the version of HIV currently prevalent in the world. There may be one in the future for the spent and evolved HIV. That will make little difference to those who are already infected. The United States and other advanced countries have devoted huge resources to make up for their initial laxity, but it is not likely that Ukraine will have such resources to devote to the AIDS epidemic. UKRAINE SHOULD TREAT AIDS LIKE ANY OTHER DISEASE AIDS is an infectious disease. But remarkably, New York State still may not have declared it such. Therefore, it delayed infectious controls that would be normal procedure for any infectious disease. On the other hand, declaring AIDS an infectious disease is filled with con troversy and is often seen as a violation of human rights. The more Ukraine can steer away from this confrontation the better. Ukraine has many other health-care priorities both related and unrelated to AIDS: nutrition, smoking, alcoholism, unemployment, industrial pollution, a poor medical and health infrastructure, tuberculosis, and no running water in many rural clinics. Ukraine must attend to all these issues with as much attention as possible. It must draw up well- thought-out priorities to address these issues and not neglect them because there is an AIDS epidemic in Ukraine. ORPHANS SHOULD BE THE HIGHEST PRIORIITY According to the British 'Council report on AIDS in Ukraine, the AIDS epidemic in Ukraine may create over 300,000 additional orphans in the next 15 years. Most of these children will not be infected but will be left without parents and subjected to a child-care system that is ill prepared to deal with them. In any country, every child, even an orphan and even one infected with HIV, should be a treasure. SO WHAT DOES THIS HAVE TO DO WITH CHERNOBYL? Nothing! The Human Immunodeficiency Virus arrived in Ukraine at about the time of the Chernobyl accident. The Ukrainian nation at home and abroad more than addressed the past issue of Chernobyl. It in turn neglected the future epidemic of AIDS. Chernobyl killed a few thousand in Ukraine. The first affected were the firefighters and safety workers. Several thousand children and now adults born before 1986 will have suffered from thyroid cancer. Background radiation, both natural and from Chernobyl, will have undoubtedly no medically recognized condition called "Chernobyl AIDS." Real AIDS will kill a few hundred thousand at the very least. You are infinitely more likely to catch HIV from sexual contact or from a dirty needle than you am from walking through or even living in Slavutych or Pripyat. Now that Ukraine has devoted 15 years to Chernobyl, it should devote similar attention to the Human Immunodeficiency Virus. Bohdan A. Oryshkevich, MD, MPH practices medicine in a clinic for poor patients in inner-city Brooklyn, New York. He welcomes commentary by E-mail [mailto:bao23@columbia.edu] Click on "BACK" to return to the News